SEO Strategy

Where did that number come from?

How to measure SEO ROI when your tracking is broken, for marketing leads who have to defend the organic number to their CEO, CFO or board.

Illustration of a person walking right, up four glowing steps, away from a tangle of crossed lines and two charts that disagree

Highlights

  • When leadership asks where a number came from, they're deciding how much of your report to believe.
  • Label every organic number as a fact, an estimate or an assumption, and say which one it is.
  • Agree what counts as a lead, a source and a time window with finance before the review, not in it.

This year I had sales calls with heads of marketing at eleven B2B companies. In ten of them, the same problem came up: they could not show what organic search brings to their CEO, their CFO or their board.

Most of them were trying to find a better number. What they needed was a more honest one, and the 3 labels I put on every organic number before it goes upstairs.

What the question means

When a CEO or CFO asks where a number came from, they're rarely checking your maths. They're deciding how much of the rest of your report to believe. If one organic figure falls apart in the room, paid, events and pipeline get questioned with it.

Organic is the easiest number to attack. There is no invoice per click. Results come months after the work. And it overlaps with everything else: brand, events, word of mouth, and now AI answers, where someone reads about you in ChatGPT and then searches your name. AI search is part of SEO, and it makes the attribution even harder.

The ROI formula won't save you either. Revenue from organic, minus what you spent, divided by what you spent: simple on paper, hard to fill in. The cost is spread over people's time and shared content. The revenue arrives months later, keeps coming for years, and some of those buyers would have found you anyway. Nobody in that room has a clean version, so don't pretend to have one.

Separate what you know from what you think

This is the move that changes the conversation. Before any organic number goes in a report, give it one of three labels.

LabelWhat it meansHow it sounds (made-up numbers)
FactCounted, from a source you can show"41 demo requests came from organic search visits this quarter. That's a minimum, because analytics misses people who decline cookies."
EstimateCalculated from facts, with the method on the table"With our usual close rate, those requests are worth €120k to €180k in pipeline."
AssumptionWhat you believe but can't show yet"We think part of our 'direct' leads started with a search or an AI answer. We can't prove it yet, and here's how we'll find out."

Three rules go with it. Never present an estimate as a fact. Give estimates as a range, because a single number invites someone to find the one thing wrong with it. And say your assumptions out loud, because leadership will find them anyway, and it's better if they hear them from you.

For me, a smaller number you can explain beats a big one you can't. A workplace hardware company I worked with had a comparison page with fewer than 10 clicks a month. In a traffic report, a failure. In the CRM, it had brought in 11 leads, more than any other page. The fact that mattered was in the CRM, not in the traffic report. It's in the client results of my revenue playbook.

Agree the rules before the meeting, not in it

Most fights about the organic number happen in the quarterly review, which is the worst place to have them. Settle these with finance and sales before:

  • What a lead is. One sentence your head of sales signs off on, for example "a request sales accepted as a fit". Without it, marketing reports leads, sales reports deals, and the two never meet.
  • Which source counts. Where the buyer first came from, not the last click before the form. Otherwise every lead that saw an ad at the end becomes a paid lead.
  • Which time window. Organic takes months. Comparing one quarter to the one before mostly measures seasons. Compare to the same quarter last year, or to a rolling six months.

Once the definitions are theirs too, the number stops being yours alone to defend. That's also why I start every engagement in the client's CRM, not in an SEO tool.

Put organic in money they already use

A CFO doesn't think in clicks. Two translations work.

What it would cost to buy the same visits. Take the searches you rank for and what advertisers pay per click on them. That's the ad spend organic saves you every month. It's not revenue, so say that, but it's a number finance recognises.

What the alternative costs. Many CFOs compare any marketing spend to a full-time hire. Put what you spend on organic next to that, and next to what you'd need to spend on ads for the same leads.

When they ask what organic could be worth, don't guess. The SEO ROI calculator gives a 12-month range from your own numbers: searches for what you sell, visitor-to-lead rate, close rate and deal value. It's a model, so it's an estimate, and you label it as one.

Ask for the fixes, don't do them yourself

The tracking still needs fixing, but it's not your job to set it up. Ask whoever runs your CRM, in house or at an agency, for three things:

  1. Keep where every lead first came from, never overwrite it, and pass it on to the deal.
  2. Make every form on the website send the page and the source with the lead.
  3. Add a free-text "How did you hear about us?" field to the demo form. If most deals come from partners or events, ask it on the first sales call instead.

I only did the second one on my own site this month. Until 13 November 2026, my contact form told my CRM who wrote to me, but not from which page.

The fixes take days. The data takes a full sales cycle: if deals take five months to close, the first pipeline number you can call a fact comes five months later. Say that upstairs now.

What I'd say in the next review

"Here's what we know: [the facts]. Here's what we estimate, and how: [the range]. Here's what we assume and can't show yet: [the assumptions]. The tracking fix is done by [date], and from [quarter] the pipeline number moves from estimate to fact."

That answer doesn't make the number bigger. It shows you know exactly where it comes from, and gives them a date. That's what they were asking for.

Before your next review, take the organic lines in your last report and label each one: fact, estimate or assumption. If most turn out to be assumptions, you know what to fix first. And if nobody on the team has time to own organic, that's the gap a fractional SEO lead fills for a few months, then hands back.

I’m a revenue-first SEO consultant for B2B and SaaS teams. 14+ years of hands-on work, from in-house at Mollie to new websites for Backbase and Rentman. I also run the Amsterdam SEO Salon.

Follow me on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)

See how this plays out with a real client

Ready to turn SEO into a real growth driver?

Let’s talk about it
Back to top