Leadership

Five questions to ask your marketing lead about organic

For board members and CEOs who want a case for organic search they can approve. Five questions, what a good answer sounds like, and the red flags. Ten minutes in a board meeting.

Illustration of a boardroom table with five question cards above it and a chart on the wall

Highlights

  • You don't need to understand SEO to judge it. Ask about leads, pages, owners and priorities.
  • A good answer has a number, a name or a page in it. A red flag is a ranking, a tool or a plan with no owner.
  • If the first two questions have no answer, fund fixing that first, not more content.

Board meetings get one slide on organic search, usually a traffic line going up and a list of keywords. It's hard to approve a budget from that, and harder to say no to it.

This is for the board member or CEO who wants a case they can judge. You don't need to understand SEO to judge it. You need five questions, and a sense of what a good answer sounds like. Together they take about ten minutes.

The five questions

AskA good answerA red flag
1. How many leads did organic bring last quarter, and how do you know?A number, with where it comes from and what it can't seeTraffic, rankings, or "it's hard to measure" with nothing after it
2. Which five pages bring those leads?Five named pages, each with its leadsA list of keywords, or "the blog"
3. What do AI assistants say about us, and does it match what we say?Someone has asked ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, and knows where the answers differNobody has looked, or a tool score with no examples
4. Who owns organic, and what result are they on the hook for?A name and a result in leads or pipeline"The agency", or a list of tasks
5. What's the one organic priority this quarter, and what are we not doing because of it?One thing, a date, and what was dropped to make roomFive priorities, or none

Question 1. Most companies can't track organic leads perfectly, and that's fine. A trustworthy answer says what it counts, what it misses and how big the gap is. I wrote about what an organic number you can trust looks like, for the CFO in the room.

Question 2 is the one that tells you whether the team knows its own website. Leads come from a few pages, and those pages are fragile. I've written up a calculator page where leads fell from 19 to 8 a month within two weeks of its copy being cut. If nobody can name the five pages, nobody is protecting them.

Question 3 is newer. Buyers and investors now ask AI assistants about a company before they visit its website, and the answers come from other people's pages as much as yours. Ramon Eijkemans calls that version of you shadow reputation. Checking it takes an hour a quarter, no tools needed.

Question 4. Organic without an owner turns into documents nobody acts on. The owner doesn't need to be senior, but they need time and a result to deliver.

Question 5 shows whether there's a plan or a wish list. I wrote about how to sort requests and pick one priority when every week brings a new AI headline.

What to do with the answers

If your marketing lead can answer all five in ten minutes, approve the budget. The team knows what organic brings, where it comes from and what it's doing next.

If questions 1 and 2 have no answer, fund fixing that first, not more content. More content on a website where nobody knows which pages bring leads is spend you can't judge. Fixing the measurement takes weeks, not quarters.

If a relaunch or a merger is coming, ask the questions about the revenue at risk before you approve it. More posts for leaders who own the SEO budget are on SEO leadership. And if the honest answer to question 4 is "nobody", a fractional SEO lead can own it for a few months and hand it back with the five answers written down.

I’m a revenue-first SEO consultant for B2B and SaaS teams. 14+ years of hands-on work, from in-house at Mollie to new websites for Backbase and Rentman. I also run the Amsterdam SEO Salon.

Follow me on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)

See how this plays out with a real client

Ready to turn SEO into a real growth driver?

Let’s talk about it
Back to top