Highlights
- A relaunch is not just a design decision. It decides the pages that bring your organic leads. Ask about them first.
- Put a number on it: organic leads through the pages that change × what a lead is worth × months to recover.
- Don't approve until someone can name those pages and who owns them through the launch.
A relaunch usually reaches the board as a design decision: a new look, a new platform, a date. The budget covers what you'll spend. It rarely covers what you could lose in organic search: the leads that come from Google and AI assistants without paying for each click.
This is for the CEO or board member asked to approve one. A new website is not just a design decision. It's a decision about the pages that bring your organic leads. The design is the visible part. The risk sits in what happens to those pages in search, and whether anyone is watching them.
Five questions before you approve
| Ask | A good answer | A red flag |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Which pages bring our organic leads, and do they survive the new site? | A short named list, usually 5 to 20 pages, each with its new address | "All pages are moving", or nobody knows |
| 2. How will we judge the launch, and who agreed it? | Organic leads and visits to those pages from search, agreed in writing before launch | "We'll watch the traffic" |
| 3. Who owns SEO in the project? | A name, with time in the plan | "The developers handle SEO" |
| 4. What is the organic revenue at risk, and for how long? | A number in euros, with the assumptions written down | No number, or only a cost for the build |
| 5. What is the go or no-go, and who decides? | Criteria agreed before launch, and a name next to the decision | The date decides |
Question 1 is the one that matters most. If nobody can name the pages that bring the organic leads, the relaunch isn't ready, however good the design looks.
When I led SEO in-house at Mollie, the relaunch of 2,011 pages was explained to the CMO, CCO, CTO, CPO and CEO four weeks before launch: what a relaunch does to organic traffic, what to expect, and what I'd watch. Decisions came with their cost attached. Not moving 20% of the pages cost 1% of organic traffic and one conversion, measured before anyone approved it. That's the Mollie relaunch, and it's the standard I'd hold any team to.
What the revenue at risk looks like
The sum is simple:
Organic revenue at risk = organic leads a month lost on the pages that change × what a lead is worth × months to recover
Here it is with example numbers. Say organic search brings 40 leads a month, 24 of them through pages the relaunch changes, and each lead is worth €1,500 in pipeline. If those pages lose half their organic leads, that's 12 a month, so a drop caught in week one is 12 × €1,500 × 3 months = €54,000:
| If the drop is | Months to recover | Organic leads lost | Pipeline at risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Caught in week one and fixed | about 3 | 36 | €54,000 |
| Caught at month three | about 12 | 144 | €216,000 |
| A domain change that goes the average way | about 17 | 204 | €306,000 |
The recovery times come from what I see on launches, which I wrote up in what dip is normal after a new website, and how long recovery takes. The last row uses the largest study I know of: across 892 domain migrations, Search Engine Journal found the new domain took 523 days on average to get its organic traffic back.
None of this has to happen. On the four launches I've written up, nobody needed a recovery, and at Bedrijfsfitness Nederland weekly leads were up 21% by the week after launch. The table is what you're protecting, not what you should expect. To run it with your own figures, use the SEO ROI calculator.
If two websites are merging
A merger after an acquisition or a rebrand carries every risk of a relaunch, twice. Two sets of pages bring organic leads, both sites rank for some of the same searches, and only one page can win each of those. And if a new domain is involved, it starts with none of the trust Google gave the old ones. It has to earn that first, through the redirects and the links from other sites, before its pages can rank like the old ones did. Add one question:
6. Which domain survives, and did anyone look at the numbers? Teams often pick on brand feeling alone. The survivor deserves data: the links from other sites each domain has, the searches that bring leads on each, and how much traffic is people looking for the brand by name, which follows the company anyway. A brand-new domain for both takes the longest to recover. I wrote out the full playbook for merging two websites into one.
When to say not yet
Approve the relaunch when questions 1 to 5 have answers on paper. Say not yet when they don't, even if the design is ready. A month's delay costs less than the middle row of that table.
If a redesign is on the table, I wrote about what a website redesign can cost you in leads, and how to keep them. And if you want an outside answer to all five questions before you sign, that's the New Website Risk Assessment: the pages that bring your leads, the revenue at risk, the risks ranked and a go or fix-first verdict, in five business days.

I’m a revenue-first SEO consultant for B2B and SaaS teams. 14+ years of hands-on work, from in-house at Mollie to new websites for Backbase and Rentman. I also run the Amsterdam SEO Salon.
Follow me on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)