Leadership

What does organic search return, and when?

Is SEO worth it, and how long does it take? When I'd tell a company not to invest, and the honest payback timeline for everyone else, before you approve the budget.

Illustration of a person standing between an hourglass and a line that stays flat for a while, then rises steeply

Highlights

  • SEO is not worth it for every company. Know the cases before you approve anything.
  • For everyone else, judge it on a timeline that includes your sales cycle, not on the first quarter.
  • Results are slow to build and fast to lose. Approving a project and stopping at month three is the expensive option.

On sales calls I tell some companies not to buy SEO. Not every business needs it, and a CFO is right to ask before approving the budget. So here is when I'd say no, and what the timeline looks like for everyone else.

When SEO isn't worth it

Nobody will publish or change anything. SEO advice that stays in a document returns nothing. If the team has no time to write, and the developers have no room to make changes, fix that first. Otherwise you're paying for a plan.

Nobody searches for what you sell, or for the problem it solves. This one is rarer than people think. Most B2B buyers do search for their problem, even when they don't know your category exists yet. But if they don't, organic search is the wrong channel.

Two reasons I often hear are not reasons to skip it.

"Our buyers already find us by name." That means your branded search works: people who know you can find you. SEO is for the people who don't know you yet, but have the problem you solve and search for it. For most B2B companies, that's the bigger group.

"We need leads this quarter." Most of what SEO returns comes later, so don't put a whole quarter's target on it. But some work is fast: a page for buyers who are already comparing you with a competitor, or fixing a page that ranks but doesn't convert, can bring leads within weeks.

If none of the real reasons fits you, organic search is usually one of the cheapest sources of pipeline over time. The question is when.

How long does SEO take?

It depends on the kind of work. This is the rule of thumb I use with clients. It's a model, not a promise, and every market moves at its own speed.

The workWhen to expect a first signalWhen to judge it
Improving pages that already rank4 to 8 weeks3 to 4 months
New pages for buyers close to a decision (comparison pages, pricing, alternatives)4 to 8 weeks3 to 6 months
New content to build a topic from scratch3 months6 months or more
A new website or a new domainThe launch week3 to 6 months after launch

Two examples from the comparison pages that brought leads at three B2B companies. At a workplace hardware company, four comparison pages reached Google's first page within 4 to 8 weeks. At a Dutch fintech lender, one comparison page brought 13 clicks in its first month and 290 a month eight months later, with 18 leads over that time.

The first signal is not the result. It's the sign the work is on track: pages live, found by Google, showing up in search, clicked. That chain is what you should see in the first months, before any lead.

Add your sales cycle

This is the part most SEO proposals leave out. Organic brings leads. Leads become revenue only after your sales cycle.

If a page needs four months to bring in its first leads, and your deals take five months to close, the first organic revenue arrives around month nine. A business case judged at month three will look like a failure, whatever the work.

So the payback date is roughly: time to the first leads, plus your sales cycle, plus the time it takes for those deals to cover the spend. The SEO ROI calculator works this out from your own numbers: searches for what you sell, your visitor-to-lead rate, close rate and deal value. Use your CRM numbers, not industry averages.

When it works, it compounds. At a Series A HealthTech company, organic conversions doubled in six months, from about 475 to about 950 a month, and the results held after I handed the work over.

Slow to build, fast to lose

I've seen a page lose more than half its leads in 2 weeks. A B2B financial services company cut the copy under the calculator on its main product page. In two weeks, leads from that page went from 19 a month to 8. By the time we noticed, a month had passed, and the copy went back. Five months on, the page still hadn't won back its position.

For a CFO, this changes the budget question. Approving SEO for one quarter and stopping is the most expensive option: you pay for the slow part and stop before the return. And once organic brings pipeline, a website change, a cut or a new site can take it away much faster than it came.

What to ask for before you approve

Four things, in writing:

  1. A baseline. Organic leads and pipeline today, so you know what you're comparing against. If the CRM can't show them, fixing that is the first piece of work.
  2. A range, not a promise. Anyone who promises a ranking or a number of leads by a date is guessing. Ask for a low and a high case, and what each depends on.
  3. A checkpoint. A date, usually three months in, with what "on track" means at that point: pages live, found by Google, getting clicks, first leads.
  4. An exit. What happens if the checkpoint is missed. A good partner will tell you when to stop.

That last one matters to me. If the work isn't moving, I'd rather a client stops than keeps paying for it.

I’m a revenue-first SEO consultant for B2B and SaaS teams. 14+ years of hands-on work, from in-house at Mollie to new websites for Backbase and Rentman. I also run the Amsterdam SEO Salon.

Follow me on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)

See how this plays out with a real client

Ready to turn SEO into a real growth driver?

Let’s talk about it
Back to top