Highlights
- When organic leads stall, more content is the most common answer and often the wrong one.
- Check three suspects in order, tracking, then Google and AI assistants, then the content, and spend 1 week on it.
- Start from the leads and walk back, not from traffic or rankings.
Organic leads go down. Someone says the content isn't good enough, or Google changed something. The team writes more, or hires someone to write more. Three months later, nothing has moved.
I see this a lot, and I'm not the only one. Marketing leads say the same thing on Reddit: months went into the content before anyone found out the real problem was the tracking, or the pages not being found. More content is the most expensive way to find out it wasn't the content.
Before you spend a quarter on it, spend 1 week finding the cause. There are three suspects, and the order matters, because each one is cheaper to rule out than the next.
Start from the leads, not from traffic
Start with the number that matters, usually leads or pipeline, and walk back one question at a time:
- Leads down? Check whether fewer people came from search, or the same number came and fewer filled in the form.
- Fewer people came? Check whether you were shown less, in Google and in AI answers, or shown as often and clicked less.
- Same number came, fewer forms? Then the problem is on the page or in the form, not in search.
Each answer either clears a suspect or points at it. Traffic and rankings come in along the way, as explanations. They're not the starting point.
1. Tracking: did the leads drop, or did the counting break?
Check this first. It takes a day, and it's the cause more often than anyone wants to admit.
What it looks like: a sudden drop on a specific date, often the week of a website change, a new cookie banner or a new form. Real demand rarely falls off a cliff overnight.
How to check:
- Fill in your own form. Does the lead arrive in the CRM, with its source?
- Does sales still get the same number of requests? If only the report dropped, it's tracking.
- Where do visits from AI assistants end up? People who click a link in ChatGPT or Perplexity often show up as "direct", or as a referral from chatgpt.com. If nobody looks at those, a shift from Google to AI answers looks like a loss.
Who fixes it: whoever runs your website forms and CRM. Usually a day or two of work.
2. Google and AI assistants: can they still see and show your pages?
If the tracking is fine, check how search engines see the site, which is not how you see it. A page can look perfect in your browser and be close to invisible to Google, or to the crawlers AI assistants use to find and quote pages.
What it looks like: a drop that follows a website change, a new platform, a redesign or a migration. Specific pages lose their place in search while the rest holds.
How to check, starting with your pages that bring leads:
- Are they still in Google's index, its list of pages it can show? Search Console, Google's free report on your search traffic, tells you.
- Did the number of times they appear in search drop? From which date?
- Did the website change around that date? Think of redirects (instructions that send visitors from an old page address to a new one), content that only appears after a click, or a new template.
- Can AI assistants read them? Their crawlers often can't see content that needs JavaScript to appear, so check what the page shows without it. And check your site isn't blocking those crawlers by accident.
- Do AI assistants still mention you? Ask ChatGPT and Perplexity the questions your buyers ask, and see whether your company comes up.
Who fixes it: your developer, with someone who can tell them what to change.
This is where a check booked in advance pays off. After Bedrijfsfitness Nederland launched its new website, the week-one review found broken pages had jumped from 26 to 130. The fix went live within days, and leads went up during the new website's launch week instead of down.
3. The content: did demand change, or does the page no longer answer it?
Only when tracking and visibility are cleared is it time to look at the content. Even then, there are several different problems behind "the content isn't working".
Fewer people search for it. The market moved, or the season did. The fix isn't on your site. Check the same months last year before anything else.
People search differently. More buyers now ask an AI assistant a long, specific question, get a shortlist, and then search your company name. Google sees fewer searches for the problem and more for your brand. The demand didn't disappear. It moved, and your report needs to show both.
People still search, but click less. You appear as often, but someone else gets the click: a competitor, a comparison site, or an AI answer at the top of the results that already tells the buyer what they wanted. The fix is a page that offers what a summary can't: your own numbers, your own cases, an honest comparison. Those are also the pages AI assistants quote.
The page changed, or the competition did. I've seen a page lose more than half its leads in two weeks because part of the copy under its calculator was cut. Nobody suspected the content, because the change looked harmless.
Who fixes it: the content team, with a clear brief on what the page is missing. This is the only one of the three where more content is the answer.
Before you hire help
If you bring in an outside SEO, watch how they start. Buyers on Reddit describe the good sign well: they ask for access to Search Console on the first call, and come back with a hypothesis before they propose anything. If someone proposes a content plan or a monthly fee before they've looked, they're guessing too.
That's how I start as well: a free strategy call, the data first, then a view on what's wrong. If a new website went live and organic leads fell, the SEO recovery triage for a new website finds the cause in three business days.
This week, do the first check yourself. Fill in your own form, and see what reaches the CRM. If it's broken, you've saved yourself a quarter of content.

I’m a revenue-first SEO consultant for B2B and SaaS teams. 14+ years of hands-on work, from in-house at Mollie to new websites for Backbase and Rentman. I also run the Amsterdam SEO Salon.
Follow me on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)