SEO Strategy

Tool or person? When an SEO tool is enough, and when it isn't

Many B2B companies buy an SEO tool and barely use it. When a tool is enough, when you need a person, and what the tool costs you, from someone who builds SEO tools himself.

Illustration of a large dashboard full of glowing gauges, with a person in front of it pointing at the one gauge that matters

Highlights

  • A tool gives you information, not priorities. Deciding what matters is the part that needs a person.
  • The cost of a tool is the hours to use it well, not the licence.
  • Before you renew, ask what the tool changed in the last three months. If nothing, it was a person problem.

Of the 11 companies I spoke with on sales calls this year, 4 had bought an SEO tool and barely used it. In every case the reasoning made sense at the time: SEO felt like a gap, a tool was cheaper than a person, and the demo looked like it would tell the team what to do.

I'm not against tools. I build them. The non-commodity content checker and the SEO ROI calculator on this site are mine. Two more are still in development and already in use with clients: Migrate watches a website through a migration and after launch, and Unprompted finds what buyers ask before they ever type a search. That's why I know what tools can't do.

What tools do well

Tools are good at the parts of SEO that are about volume and speed.

  • Collecting data. Which searches you show up for, which pages lost ground, what competitors rank for.
  • Watching. Alerts when a page drops out of Google, when a redirect breaks, when a website change goes wrong.
  • Repeating. Checks that would take a person hours, done in minutes, every week.

They also make a team faster. At one client, a brief generator cut the time to write a content brief from about two hours to 15 minutes, so a team with no SEO person could keep publishing. It's in the B2B SEO ROI results in my revenue playbook.

What tools can't do

Decide what matters. A tool will always find issues. An audit can list 300 of them, and maybe five matter for your leads. A tool gives you information, not priorities. Picking the five is the actual work.

Know your buyers. A tool sees search terms. It doesn't hear sales calls, read the questions in your CRM, or know which competitor your buyers keep comparing you with.

Get things done inside the company. Most SEO work needs a developer's time, a decision from leadership or input from sales. A dashboard doesn't get a ticket prioritised.

Take responsibility. When organic drops, the tool shows the drop. Someone still has to say why, and what to do about it.

Tool or person? A quick test

Your situationWhat you need
You know what to do and need data to do itA tool
Someone on the team knows SEO and has the timeA tool
Nobody can say which three things matter most this quarterA person
A new website, a merger or a new market is comingA person, with a tool to watch the launch
Leadership wants a business case before more budgetA person
The tool shows problems and nothing gets fixedA person, not a better tool

Most of the four companies that bought a tool and didn't use it were in the third row. They bought the tool to answer a question it can't answer.

What a tool costs you

For a CFO, the licence is the visible cost. It's rarely the real one.

A tool nobody opens costs the licence. Annoying, but small.

A tool someone half-uses costs more: the licence, plus the hours spent on what the tool points at instead of what brings leads. Audit scores go up, and pipeline doesn't move.

A tool used well needs someone with the skill and the time to turn its data into decisions. If that person exists, the tool is cheap. If they don't, you've bought half of a solution.

So the useful comparison isn't tool against consultant. It's a tool plus the hours of someone who can use it, against a person who sets the direction for a few months and leaves your team able to use the tool on its own.

The tools I use, and what for

People often ask me which SEO tools to buy. My answer is a short list, because most of what I rely on is the company's own data.

The jobWhat I useWhy
Watching rankings and trafficGoogle Search Console, plus GA4 at clients and Plausible on my own sitesSearch Console is Google's own data about your site. Third-party rank trackers see less of Google every year: Google has started serving poisoned results to the scrapers trackers depend on and delaying the result links they read.
Website migrationsMigrate, the migration tool I builtIt runs a migration from start to finish on my own process, so it stays short and the priority pages keep their leads and rankings.
Search volumes and competitors' resultsDataForSEO, plus Screaming Frog to crawl a siteRaw data at a low price. What to do with it is still my call.
ContentClaude skills with my own process built in, fed by calls recorded in FathomThey draft from what the company knows about its product, its market and its buyers, in the buyers' own words from sales calls. The client's team does the final pass, and the skills learn from their edits.
AI search (ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity)My own process, with DataForSEO's AI search dataI run sets of buyer questions through the assistants and count where the company is named, and where it isn't. It's directional, and I don't think paid prompt tracking is worth it yet.
StrategyMy own judgment, with Unprompted (in beta)Who buys, why, and what they search before they know you exist. Unprompted gathers what buyers ask. Deciding what to do with it stays with a person.

The pattern: tools for collecting and watching, people for deciding. Even the tools I built, Migrate and Unprompted, follow methods I ran by hand for years before I put them in code.

How I combine them

In my own work, the tools collect and check, and a person decides. When I leave a client, what stays is the way of working and the tools they can run themselves, not a dependency on me or on a licence they need me to read.

If you have a tool already, keep it. Just check what it's for. Before the next renewal, ask one question: what did this tool change in the last three months? If the answer is a list of decisions and pages, renew it. If the answer is a dashboard, the gap was never the tool. That's when it makes sense to hire an SEO consultant who answers for pipeline, not rankings, and keep the tool for the work it does well.

I’m a revenue-first SEO consultant for B2B and SaaS teams. 14+ years of hands-on work, from in-house at Mollie to new websites for Backbase and Rentman. I also run the Amsterdam SEO Salon.

Follow me on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)

See how this plays out with a real client

Ready to turn SEO into a real growth driver?

Let’s talk about it
Back to top