Leadership

SEO help against a full-time hire: the comparison a CFO should make

Most finance teams compare any SEO fee with a salary. A like-for-like comparison of an agency, a freelancer, a fractional lead and a full-time hire, with the costs a salary leaves out.

Illustration of a balance scale with a single salary coin on one side and a stack of smaller cost blocks on the other

Highlights

  • Compare year one, all costs included, not a monthly fee against a salary.
  • A full-time SEO lead in the Netherlands costs from €98,000 in the first year before tools, and starts about two months after you decide.
  • The hire wins when SEO is a permanent, central channel and someone senior can manage it. Until then, it's usually the most expensive option.

On a sales call this year, a head of marketing described how his finance team decides: any yearly fee close to a salary counts as a full-time hire, and gets judged that way. It's a sensible rule. It's also how a company ends up comparing a salary on a payslip with an invoice that covers everything, and picking the option that looks cheaper on paper.

I sell one of the options below, a fractional SEO lead. So read my numbers with that in mind: every figure has its source, and I've written down when the full-time hire is the better choice.

Compare the first year, all costs included

A salary is the visible cost of a hire. A CFO should compare what each option costs in its first year, and when the work starts. For a full-time SEO lead in the Netherlands, the floor looks like this:

Cost lineFirst year, from
Salary for an SEO lead who can own the strategy€70,000
Employer costs on top of salary, at least 20%€14,000
Recruiter fee, usually 20% to 25% of the yearly salary€14,000
Total before tools, a laptop and onboarding€98,000

The salary is a floor: a 2026 Dutch salary overview puts a senior SEO specialist at €58,000, with another 22% on average for the step to lead. Employer costs add 20 to 35 percent on top of the gross salary, and Dutch recruitment fees run at 20 to 25 percent of the yearly salary. Once tools and onboarding are in, I round the full first year to from €110,000 on my page about hiring in-house SEO or bringing in a consultant.

Then there's time. Marketing leaders report five weeks on average to hire for a permanent role, and the person you hire usually has a notice period of a month or more. So day one is about two months after you decide, and the first months after that go to learning your product, your buyers and your website.

Four options, like for like

First, what each option costs:

OptionA monthFirst year, all in
AgencyAbout €2,800 on averageAbout €33,500
FreelancerAbout €1,200 on averageAbout €14,000
Fractional SEO lead (my price)From €7,500€67,500 for nine months
Full-time hireFrom €70,000 salary a yearFrom €98,000 before tools

Then what the fee doesn't show:

OptionYour team's timeWork startsIf it's the wrong choice
AgencyBriefs, reviews, chasingAfter onboardingThe notice in the contract
FreelancerBriefs, checking each taskWhen you agree a taskYou stop
Fractional SEO leadA short weekly check-inAfter the contractYou stop
Full-time hireManaging the roleAbout two months laterA new search

The agency and freelancer figures are averages from an SEO pricing survey of 439 providers, reported in dollars ($3,209 and $1,349 a month) and converted at about €0.87 to the dollar in November 2026. The first-year figures for those two are twelve times that average, my own sum.

Three things this table shows that a fee alone doesn't.

Price per month says little about who decides. An agency at the survey average is cheaper than my fee. If your team already knows which three pages to build and why, that's a good deal. If nobody can say what matters most this quarter, you're paying someone to wait for instructions. I wrote about that gap in when a tool or a person is the right answer.

Your team's time is a cost too. An agency or a freelancer needs briefs, reviews and someone to chase them. That time comes from your marketing lead, usually the person who has the least of it, and it never shows up on an invoice. As a fractional lead, I take that time off people: I set the priorities with you, write the briefs, check the work and make the calls, so your team gets a short check-in a week instead of a second job.

The cost of a wrong choice is part of the price. A freelancer you can stop next week. An agency has a notice period. A permanent hire who turns out to be the wrong fit costs the salary while you find out, and then the search starts again. You can stop my engagement when you want, and it's built to end on a planned date anyway, so there's no exit cost to plan for. The full breakdown of what I charge is on my pricing page.

What waiting costs

The cheapest option on paper is often the one that leaves organic without an owner for months: while you search, while the hire works their notice, while they learn the business. Nothing breaks on day one. Things drift.

It can go fast. On one site, the copy under a calculator was cut, and leads from that page fell from 19 to 8 a month within two weeks. Nobody was watching that page for organic. Every month without an owner is a month where a change like that goes unnoticed.

So I'd add one line to the comparison: what does the gap cost? Take the leads your organic pages bring each month, and ask how many months the option you're leaning towards leaves them without someone looking.

When the hire wins

I'm not against hiring. A full-time SEO lead is the right choice when organic is a permanent, central channel for the company and someone senior can manage the role. Then the higher first-year cost buys you someone who stays, learns the business deeply and builds a team over the years.

What I see go wrong is the order. A company hires before anyone knows what the role should do, the new person spends their first six months finding out, and the CFO asks at month nine what the €98,000 bought. A few months of outside help first, with the setup documented and the priorities clear, makes the hire faster to pay off, or shows you don't need one yet.

If you want to run the numbers for your own company, a free strategy call is the place to start. I'll tell you which of the four I'd pick in your situation, including when it isn't me.

I’m a revenue-first SEO consultant for B2B and SaaS teams. 14+ years of hands-on work, from in-house at Mollie to new websites for Backbase and Rentman. I also run the Amsterdam SEO Salon.

Follow me on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)

See how this plays out with a real client

Ready to turn SEO into a real growth driver?

Let’s talk about it
Back to top