Leadership

Your first 90 days with outside SEO help: what to agree before day one

Leadership backs SEO, brings in outside help, then wants results by the next quarter. What to agree before the first call, what to expect at 30, 60 and 90 days, and what a CEO should ask at the end.

Illustration of two people shaking hands next to a calendar with three months checked off

Highlights

  • Agree what counts as a result before day one: leads and pipeline, not rankings, traffic or tasks done.
  • Name who owns it on your side, and what happens when something stalls, in writing.
  • At day 90, expect early signs and a clear plan, not the full result. Judge on what you agreed.

This is for the marketing lead about to bring in outside SEO help (an agency, a freelancer or a consultant), and for the CEO who approved the budget.

The pattern goes like this. Leadership agrees SEO matters, outside help comes in, and three months later the CEO asks what it brought. Nobody agreed what "brought" means, so one side shows rankings and traffic, the other asks about pipeline, and both feel let down.

A marketer on Reddit put the fix well: decide before you talk to anyone what success looks like in 90 days, who owns the relationship day to day, and what happens when a campaign isn't moving. I'd add two more. Below are the five things I'd agree before anyone starts, and there's a free 90-day agreement with a checklist and a Claude prompt to write yours.

Agree five things before day one

1. What counts as a result. One sentence, in leads or pipeline from organic search. Not rankings, not traffic, not a list of tasks done. If you can't track leads from organic yet, say so, and make fixing that part of the first month. Otherwise the 90-day review is about whatever number the outside party picks.

2. Who owns it on your side. A name and a number of hours a week. Outside help without an inside owner produces documents nobody acts on. The owner doesn't need SEO skills. They need the time to make decisions and get tickets done.

3. What happens when something stalls. Write the rule before you need it: "if this page isn't indexed by week 6, we change the approach." It turns a stall into a decision instead of an argument.

4. How it's reported. I report every month in the same order: what happened, why it matters, what changed, what it means, what's next. Whatever format you pick, agree it before the first report, and keep the agreed result at the top.

5. When it ends, and what stays. An end date and a handover list: the decisions written down, the accounts in the company's name, your team able to do part of the work. My own nine-month engagements are built to end on a planned date, and I think every outside engagement should know its end before it starts.

What to expect at 30, 60 and 90 days

Organic search is slow at the start and then compounds. This is roughly what each stage should show, and what it's too early for:

By dayYou should seeToo early for
30A baseline you both trust, three priorities with the effect you expect, the first work startedJudging results
60The first pages or fixes live and found by Google, the stall rule checked on its dateChanging direction on one week of data
90Early signs on the agreed result, a clear decision on what's nextThe full result on most pages

How fast the early signs come depends on the work. At a workplace hardware company, four comparison pages for buyers weighing a competitor reached Google's first page within 4 to 8 weeks. At a Dutch fintech lender, one comparison page went from 13 clicks in its first month to 290 a month eight months later. That page took months to show in clicks, and it brought 18 leads by June 2026. At day 90 it looked like a slow start.

That's why the agreed result matters more than the 90-day number. If you judge on traffic at day 90, you stop the work that was about to pay off.

For the CEO: what to ask at day 90

If you approved the budget, three questions at the day-90 review:

  • What was the result we agreed, and where are we against it? If nobody can say what was agreed, that's the first thing to fix.
  • What moved, what didn't, and why? You want reasons, not activity.
  • What would you stop, and what needs more time? A good answer stops something.

If you're still deciding who to bring in, I compared the first-year cost of an agency, a freelancer, a fractional lead and a full-time hire. And if you want outside help that starts from a result in pipeline and ends on a planned date, that's how I work as a fractional SEO lead.

Before your next call with anyone selling SEO help, open the free 90-day agreement, paste its prompt into Claude, and write down your result in one sentence. Then ask them to agree to it.

I’m a revenue-first SEO consultant for B2B and SaaS teams. 14+ years of hands-on work, from in-house at Mollie to new websites for Backbase and Rentman. I also run the Amsterdam SEO Salon.

Follow me on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)

See how this plays out with a real client

Ready to turn SEO into a real growth driver?

Let’s talk about it
Back to top