Highlights
- In your first 30 days, see first, decide later: a new agency or a new website can wait four weeks.
- Week by week: access, what the website brings, the spend, then one page for your CEO.
- Judge pages on leads, not visits. The page with the fewest visits can be the one that brings the most.
5 of the 11 marketing leads I spoke with on sales calls this year were new in the job. Most of them told me some version of the same story: the website doesn't bring what it should from organic search, money goes to an SEO agency and a few tools, and nobody can say clearly what any of it delivers.
This article is about that organic part: how buyers find your website on Google and in AI assistants like ChatGPT, and what those visits bring. Conversion rates, design and paid campaigns matter too, but they're for another article.
The pull in that situation is to act fast. Change the agency, plan a new website, show the CEO that something is happening. I'd wait four weeks. Not to do nothing, but to find out what you inherited before you change it.
When I start with a new client, my first weeks look the same: access first, then what the site brings, before any plan. Below is that order, adapted for someone who just started in the job. There's also a free first 30 days plan with a checklist and a Claude prompt that builds it with you.
Why wait four weeks
A new website is the most expensive way to find out what the old one was doing. If you relaunch before you know which pages bring leads, you can lose them in the move and never know they were there. In my experience the pages that bring leads are few, and rarely the ones anyone points at.
The same goes for the agency. Maybe they deliver and nobody measured it. Maybe they don't. Four weeks is enough to tell the difference, and firing a good agency costs you months.
Week 1: access and owners
Before you judge anything, make sure you can see it.
- Get your own logins to Search Console, analytics, the tag manager, the CRM reports and the website editor. Not the previous person's, yours.
- List who touches the website: agency, freelancers, developers, tools, with what each does and when each contract ends. One page.
- Find out where leads are counted, and who reports them to the CEO. Ask to see last month's report and who built it.
- Talk to sales once. What do buyers ask before they buy? Which competitors come up? It's the fastest way to learn the market you're now marketing to.
If the accounts sit in someone's personal name, fix that first. My SEO succession plan has the checks for that.
Week 2: what organic search brings
This is the week that changes how you see the site. Rank pages by the leads they bring, not the visits.
Pull leads from the CRM by the page they first landed on, for the last 12 months, and filter on organic search as the source. Then compare that list with the most visited pages. They're rarely the same. At one company I worked with, a comparison page with fewer than 10 clicks a month brought in 11 leads over three months, more than any other page on the site.
Then split organic clicks in Search Console into two groups: people searching for your company name, and people searching for the problem you solve. The first group already knew you. The second is what SEO brings on its own.
You'll inherit numbers you can't fully trust. That's normal. Label each one as a fact, an estimate or an assumption before you repeat it upstairs. I wrote about what you can honestly claim about organic while the tracking is broken, and it's the same rule here: a smaller number you can explain beats a big one you can't.
Week 3: the spend
Now look at every contract and tool, and write one line for each: what it was meant to deliver, and what it delivered in the last six months.
For the agency, ask for their last three months of work tied to leads, not to rankings or a list of tasks. If they can't connect any of it to leads, that's your answer, not a reason to fire them on the spot. Read what to do when your SEO agency isn't delivering before you decide, because the problem is often the brief, not the agency.
For the tools, note who uses each one. Cancel nothing yet. Mark the candidates, and decide in week 4.
Week 4: one page for the CEO
By now you know what the website brings, what the spend buys, and where the numbers are weak. Put it on one page:
| On the page | Why |
|---|---|
| Three things you'll stop | Proof you looked before you spent |
| Two things you'll fix | Start with what blocks the pages that bring leads |
| One number you'll report every month | So the next conversation is about the same number |
The free plan has a one-page template for your CEO with these fields ready to fill in and print. Agree the number with your CEO, and put the first report date in both calendars. Fix technical problems only when they block pages that bring leads; the rest can wait. And book a review at day 90 to check the plan against the number.
If week 4 shows the plan needs expertise nobody in the team has, that's when outside help makes sense: someone who takes the organic part for a few months and hands it back documented, as a fractional SEO lead does. Agree what counts as a result before they start. I wrote down what to agree before your first 90 days with outside help.
Start this week: take the free first 30 days plan, paste its prompt into Claude, and do the week 1 checks before Friday.

I’m a revenue-first SEO consultant for B2B and SaaS teams. 14+ years of hands-on work, from in-house at Mollie to new websites for Backbase and Rentman. I also run the Amsterdam SEO Salon.
Follow me on LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)